Have you tried spinners with your students?? My students love working with spinners!
Common Core NO PREP Printable 1.OA.2 I also have spinners for Verb Tenses! My kiddos also loved working with that you can find that item here: Verb Tense Using Spinners
Maybe you don't want to 'waste' paper. I completely understand! Print enough so there's 1 for every 2 students! Put the paper in a clear plastic sleeve. Give the students 2 different color dry erase markers, and they can take turns spinning and solving! When they are done, just wipe clean, and it's ready to be used again another time!!
Come check out more hints and tips on my blog Momma with a Teaching Mission Blog or you can check out my goodies at my store Momma with a Teaching Mission TpT Store